Spot on. His confidence is utterly shot to the point of fear. Get him away from first team exposure and back to the reserves to prove himself. To keep him at full back in front of his own fans when he is scared to chase back for a ball or catch a spiralling bomb is madness and will destroy him.



Keep him out of the spotlight. Put Thorman there, cancel Motu's contract which is a drain on squad levels and resources and for fuxake, find a playmaker!

Agreed, Hall is far from an issue. And no dilemma in my book, keep him and play him centre or don't play him. He will be destroyed if we continue this crap.

Who would you put at FB?

put thorman at FB and have tommy lee at 7.

Yup

Reardon.

Out of Thorman and Horne i'd move Horne to FB and have Washy and Thorman in the halves, with Whiting at 13.

sounds ok but still don't want thorman!

He's not as bad as Agars tactics are making him look!!

Thorman was outstanding against Bradford. He was involved in nearly every try, if I remember correctly. Like it or not, he's the best tactical kicker we have and can still open a defence if the platform is set and Tickle stays 30m back.

I think it's a bit unfair to judge him right now as he's playing in a difficult position and one that he's doing for the benefit of the team. I'm prepared to wager he'd have been a better player than last year if he wasn't trying to hang onto Danny Broughs bombs and was playing in his favoured position. Also, if Justin Morgan (as much as i hate the little bugger), did at some point in the future take a punt on him he'd restore his confidence and turn him into a star.

If Reardon is not fit then I would play Whiting or Thorman at FB.