if shearer stayed with newcastle next year they'd be straight back up. Just as if he'd been there all season they wouldn't have gone down.



You can just tell whether some players would be good coaches, shearer was a leader, so was pep guardiola. They both are/will be fantastic coaches.

Same as farrell would be for us, he's just got that presence about him where you know he would be a fantastic coach.

Wild guesswork is no basis for an argument.



Wigan's next coach needs to be someone with a proven track record of all-round coaching ability. It simply doesn't add up that because you were a good player and a good club-man, you'll be a good coach. We can't afford to take any more chances. We're already well settled at mid-table level. If we get cemented into that position, the crowd will finally tail off.



What frustrates me more than anything about this is that Wigan were the first British club to actually learn this lesson.



When we appointed Graham Lowe - a foreigner with no prevous connection to Wigan, who had barely played the game at a decent level - everyone laughed at us. Saints meanwhile had re-appointed Alex Murphy and were proclaiming it the 'return of the messiah'. But who had the last laugh?



Unfortunately, now it's teams like St Helens, Hull KR and Huddersfield who have signed RL intellectuals, while we are - or we would be if some fans had their way - looking at giving the job to popular ex-players who've done little or (in Farrell's case) nothing at all on the coaching paddock.

We've had the 2 most successful coaches in the SL era, and we're still a poor side.



We need a top drawer Aussie to come in with fresh ideas. I don't agree with looking overseas, however there isn't anyone over here who I think can offer us more than Noble. I'm sure IL is looking at his options whilst in oz.

Someone who talks sense at last. Whilst people are moaning at Noble need to remember hes the most succesful coach in the SL era. Lam is not the answer. If we cant get a good NRL coach then i see nothing to gain from letting Noble leave.



Only person from these shores id have as a coach is Edwards. It would be a gamble but a better gamble than any of the other SL coaches. At least the defenc would be the best in SL. Hes worked wonders on the defences of Wasps and Wales.

The same Adrian Lam who was stood down as U20's coach part way through last season because they were bottom without a win?

I'd have lam as an assistant but we're gonna need more than him.



I've beensaying for ages that I'd love to see Ricky Stuart. Pure class as a player, trained under Wayne Bennett. He's been involved in top class rugby and club level, state of origin and internationals both as a player and coach.



Please Mr Lennigan, bring Ricky Stuart to Wigan.

A top aussie coach to hopefully have the same sort of effect that Nathan Brown has had at Huddersfield. Good discipline, better fitness, set moves and doing the basics well, Brian Smith or Ricky Stuart please

wots up with s wain as coach

As Cruncher has already said complete guesswork.



For someone with alleged leadership and motivational qualities, Shearer's Newcastle went down without a whimper yesterday. I don't think I've ever seen a more gutless performance from a team who were in Newcastle's position as the one I saw yesterday. There was nothing there at all considering they needed to get something out of the game. No fight, no passion.

If we are to replace Noble, and I'm one who would give him one more year, then Brian Smith IMO would be an ideal candidate.

1-Morgan

2-Kearney



If we push hard enough and offer a deal neither can turn down then we could have one of the above imo. Forget the likes of Bennett as he’ll stay where he is. Forget Lam as there are far better/more experienced coaches out there and forget Edwards who has said he won’t leave London till his kid is old enough or left school.



Also i realise people will say why would Morgan come and leave Hull KR when they are doing so well? But with absolutely no disrespect intended to Hull KR are they really that better than us that Morgan would think it so stupid to even consider it? The gulf may look big in league standings but it’s not a gap which would potentially put someone off who wants a challenge.



The differences between the two teams when we played were some bad decisions from Smith; Dobbo controlled the game better and most importantly a better team spirit and belief imo.



Morgan could sign a better HB and he could foster a better team belief and spirit imo.



Add on top of that the better training facilities, academy and ground we have over KR we could defiantly get him listening to offers from us. We are a big club no matter what other fans will try and tell you and we could turn the heads of most of the coaches in SL Leeds and Saints aside. Noble is proof of that.



Kearney also is a person that’s served a long and fruitful apprenticeship and he’s also dabbled in a head coaching role with NZ. He’s a well respected person who was also a great player and heads and shoulders above Lam and further developed as a coach also. If we were going to go down the road of looking for an assistant to step up to head coach Kearney is the far better choice imo.



Lam just doesn’t make sense I truly believed he would drown in the Wigan role if he was given it now. Great player without a doubt1 But was he the most professional player when compared to the likes of Faz or Rads? Not from what I remember, saw or heard about during his time here. Far, far to much risk involved

I would like Smith Coach/Director of rugby in with Lam as assistand/head coach, depending on what role Smith would be plced in.