=#8040FFMorrison is too injury prone and moans more then McGoldrick! Obst maybe, depends on the sort of game you're going into.

Well your original post suggest you was using it as an excuse. So in this post you move on to blaming the ref! Yet more victim thinking, just accept you are a poor team put together on the cheap! Like us your no way near spending up to the full cap. The soloution to your current problems lay within the club not outside!

Well he is not missed one game this year at Wakey. He could of been just unlucky at the Bulls. His form as been excellent. Could you honestly say that you would rather have Touson in the back row than Morrison. Could you honestly say that Jones would make a better hooker than Obst in what ever game your playing?

Gleadhill

=#8000FFMurhpy & Blanch are better then Ainscough & Dixon? I don't think so

Higgins is a prop, so I don't think Ferguson would be an improvement there

JD isn't as good as Snitch, Jones, Westerman so wouldn't get in.

Murphy - you may live to regret that one, very good player IMO.

Oh come on, it's a few more than that. Moore is a better prop than any you have for starters. I don't think you would turn your noses up at Morrison, Ferguson, Henderson (who ripped you to bits) Jeffries, Obst (who outplayed Hudson AGAIN) or Cooke. They would all improve your team.



Yes I'd take a few of yours, but to pretend a team on twice the points doesn't have more than two players you would want is frankly absurd.



Snitch by the way has gone backwards, not half the player he was last year which is a shame.

i wouldnt argue with you, i would take a minimum of 6 of yours over that shower of ours and for anyone to say differenty is just sour grapes, i think last night showed for anyone in any doubt that this is the worst cas side since the one that got relegated in 04, snitch is going back week on week under mattersons masterplan and as for sarge beng rested/dropped its not before time for me as he has looked to be marking time untill he goes back to oz since the start of the season. but the worst thing for me about last night is that wakey were no great shakes but they were far better than us, but not to worry its only saints on monday.

=#8000FFMoore isn't as good as Huby so that's wrong for a start, Henderson is average at best - your Clayton. Cooke wouldn't get in the side, Chase is better, Westerman is better.



And don't over rate Murphy, wait for him to do something in the league first etc etc

Where is chapster found him a job

i would have cooke in straight away at least he makes opportunities, get joe in 2nd row and running wide where he can do some damage instead of the short hospital balls he keeps getting down the middle, and i would take henderson over clayton too, infact i would take there mascott over clayton.

=#8000FFIf Cas had someone who wasn't a moron passing to Westerman (like McGoldrick now

) then playing him through the middle wouldn't be a bad thing. As for Clayton, well the water carrier is better, why doesn't he just play Holmes?!